A Procedural Giant

Scott Dodson Volume 77, Special Issue, 1-4 When I first learned of my colleague and mentor Rick Marcus’s intention to retire, I immediately thought to spearhead this written symposium in his honor. I organized one for Geoff Hazard in 2019, and Rick struck me as...

That’s Rick

Edward H. Cooper Volume 77, Special Issue, 5-10 Rick Marcus retiring? Not possible. No way. Well, I might be persuaded that he will retire from the job with a paycheck. Retiring will leave him free to go full speed ahead, engaging in the full range of his abiding...

A Set of One

David L. Faigman Volume 77, Special Issue, 17-21 In every respect, Emeritus Distinguished Professor of Law and Horace O. Coil Chair in Litigation, Richard Marcus—“Rick” to everyone who knows him—is the quintessential academic. Indeed, if one were writing a movie that...

Richard Marcus, Master of Rules

Elizabeth J. Cabraser Volume 77, Special Issue, 21-25 Many lawyers are forever indebted to Rick Marcus as a consummate professor of civil procedure, who merges the theoretical with the practical. Professor Marcus enables the students he teaches to not only think like...

Three (Unfashionable) Words About Rick Marcus

Steve Gensler Volume 77, Special Issue, 25-30 Rick Marcus rules! (Bad pun intended.) No, those aren’t my three words about Rick Marcus. Nor am I going to write that Rick is prolific, or brilliant, or gracious, or generous of spirit, or any of the other words one could...

A Reporter for All Seasons

Judge Robert M. Dow, Jr. Volume 77, Special Issue, 31-34 My introduction to Professor Richard Marcus took place on my first day of law school. It was, as we now would say, a virtual encounter. Rick was present in the form of a not inexpensive textbook: Marcus, Redish,...

Rick Marcus

Andrew Bradt Volume 77, Special Issue, 35-39 There is only one Rick Marcus. Of course, when one considers the sum of his contributions to American law—as a teacher, scholar, mentor, and public servant—it’s remarkable that there is only one Rick Marcus. I have had the...

Richard Marcus: An Encomium

Deborah R. Hensler Volume 77, Special Issue, 39-41 As long as I have researched, written, and taught complex civil litigation, Rick Marcus has been my go-to person to find out what new civil procedure rules are in the making, why, and in response to whose pleas. I am...

Discovering Rick Marcus

Diego Zambrano Volume 77, Special Issue, 47-53 No one knows more about discovery than Rick Marcus. Over the course of his career, Rick has authored the defining scholarship on our American procedural institution, from his early work on reforms to contain discovery...

The Autonomy Default Paradigm in Contract Law

Hanoch Dagan & Michael Heller Volume 77, Issue 1, 1-37 You can scribble an agreement on a napkin or hire lawyers to negotiate a hundred-page contract. Either way, most of your contractual obligations will not be in your document. They will be in the background...

Religious Freedom & the Fertilized Egg

Rabea Benhalim Volume 77, Issue 1, 166-222 Anti-abortion activism and litigation have challenged established caselaw on the legality of in vitro fertilization (IVF) and the legal treatment of IVF fertilized eggs. These challenges rely on conservative Christian...

Political Questions and the Role of Federal Courts in Deciding Claims that the Executive Branch is Violating Fundamental Norms of International Law: The Case of United States Aid for the Israeli War Against Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank

Jules Lobel Volume 76, Issue 6, 1573-1596 A recent challenge to the Biden Administration’s military aid to Israel as aiding genocide presents an important question of the role of U.S. courts in adjudicating claims that top U.S. officials, in their execution of U.S...

Freedom of Expression in Next-Generation Computing

Brittan Heller Volume 76, Issue 6, 1687-1714 Extended reality (XR)—the integration of virtual, augmented, and mixed reality technologies—creates immersive, embodied, and behaviorally integrated forms of communication that challenge traditional understandings of...

Privacy and Disinformation

Tiffany C. Li Volume 76, Issue 6, 1715-1740 All three branches of the federal government have wrestled with how the law could or should regulate social media applications to mitigate the harms of disinformation. However, most proposed solutions make the same critical...

In Place of Prison

Grace Y. Li Volume 76, Issue 5, 1307-1372 A new, previously unstudied institution is addressing felonies, including violent felonies of the highest levels, without imposing incarceration as the sanction. Attempts to abolish prisons, or at least reduce racialized mass...

The Income Tax as a Market Correction

Rebecca N. Morrow Volume 76, Issue 5, 1373-1428 I confess. As a tax professor, it has long hurt my feelings that economists label tax as a market distortion. My field is summed up as an impurity on the otherwise pristine complexion of the economist’s pure market. I...

Legal Personhood for Artwork

Sergio Alberto Gramitto Ricci Volume 76, Issue 5, 1429-1458 Artwork is unique and irreplaceable. It is signifier and signified. The signified of a work of art is its coherent purpose. But the signified of a work of art can be altered when not protected. The...

The Law of Killing for Biodiversity

David Takacs Volume 76, Issue 5, 1459-1516 In the United States, Australia, New Zealand, and elsewhere, people kill sentient creatures—by the millions every year—in the crusade to conserve biodiversity. I explain how laws permit, and in some instances require, killing...

The Essence of an Antitrust Violation

Thomas A. Lambert Volume 76, Issue 4, 1155-1226 Judicial embrace of the consumer welfare standard reduced the indeterminacy and political manipulability of U.S. antitrust law. Continual invocations of antitrust’s consumer welfare focus, however, have created the...

Digital Dollar: Privacy and Transparency Dilemma

Jiaying Jiang Volume 76, Issue 3, 629-678 Many have voiced concerns that the digital dollar, a digital form of central bank money, will facilitate government surveillance, thus depriving users of privacy. This Article investigates critical technical designs proposed...

The Case Against Surge Pricing

Ramsi A. Woodcock Volume 76, Issue 3, 821-884 Surge pricing—using data and algorithms to raise prices in response to unexpected increases in demand—has spread across the economy in recent years, from Amazon and Disney World to commuter highways and, of course, Uber,...

Beyond Privity of Blood: Intestacy and Charity

Adam J. Hirsch Volume 76, Issue 2, 353-408 When an individual dies without leaving a will, the law of intestacy functions to distribute the decedent’s estate to a surviving spouse and/or close blood relatives. Yet, this default regime fails to account for the...

Litigation as Accommodation

Matthew A. Shapiro Volume 76, Issue 2, 511-560 As persistent threats to the integrity of some of our most important public institutions remind us, every public institution faces the challenge of combating the abuse of its powers for ends inconsistent with the public...

The Federal Rules of Constitutional Procedure

Ramon Feldbrin Volume 76, Issue 1, 1-46   Judicial review has distinct purposes, difficulties, and modalities, but there are no guideposts as to how these features ought to be addressed in procedural terms. The reason is a deep-seated, but largely unarticulated,...